Showing posts with label New Hampshire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Hampshire. Show all posts

Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s 2010 IRS Form 990 -- More of the $ame

I've previously posted on the outrageous amount of money Amethyst Foundation, Inc., brings in, all tax-free.

Well, their IRS Form 990 for 2010 is now available and shows more of the same:
  • a whopping total revenue of $1,165,753.00, of which $1,161,774.00 is entirely program service revenue from the state.
And, apparently, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., operated in the red last year, with expenses of $1,185,201, including:
  • $557,353 in wages (!)  Really?
  • $76,623 for Director Bob Kelley's salary
  • $35,476 for office supplies (!!)  I saw one old HP inkjet printer when I was there.
  •  $109,868 for "all other expenses." 
And if you buy that, I have some swampland in Florida I'd like to sell you.

Forced Worship Celebrates 3000 hits

Though it doesn't sound like very much, three thousand hits is actually a fairly impressive number for a little blog like this.

Good luck to those of you who are going through what I had to go through.

Would you like your story heard?  Send it to me!

Your W/IDIP Intake Interview: Welcome My Son, Welcome To The Machine.

Your W/IDIP Intake Interview

What happens at your intake interview is dictated by He-A 707.10:
 He-A 707.10  IDIP and WIDIP Intake Interview.

      (a)  There shall be an initial one-on-one intake interview between the client and a NH LADC, or an IDIP or WIDIP staff member under LADC supervision.

      (b)  The intake interview shall take place prior to, and separate from, course sessions.

      (c)  The intake interview shall include the following steps:

(1)  Each client shall provide the IDIP or WIDIP with the documents required pursuant to He-A 704.04;

(2)  The client shall complete the DRI-II and the RIASI diagnostic instruments;

(3)  The LADC shall complete Form IDIP-011, client profile, by including the following printed or typewritten information:

a.  The facility code;

b.  The section where the client is assigned;

c.  The last four digits of the client’s Social Security number;

d.  The client’s name;

e.  The client’s initials;

f.  The program type;

g.  The client’s address;

h.  The client’s date of birth;

i.  The date of the client’s intake interview;

j.  The client’s gender;

k.  Whether the client is restarting a program;

l.  The court of the client’s conviction;

m.  The date of the client’s arrest;

n.  The client’s blood alcohol test results, or an indication of the client’s refusal of consent;

o.  All of the client’s DWI convictions, including the current one, and drug impaired driving convictions, unless otherwise protected by law;

p.  All DWI courses previously attended by the client;

q.  The client’s marital status;

r.  The client’s education level;

s.  The client’s occupation;

t.  The client’s current income;

u.  Whether the program fee was reduced due to financial hardship;

v.  The client’s history of treatment for any other alcohol or other substance abuse problem;

w.  The frequency of alcohol consumption in the past;

x.  The client’s scores on the DRI-II and RIASI diagnostic instruments; and

y.  The signature of the LADC completing the top of the form, which shall not be printed or typewritten;

(4)  The client shall provide to the LADC completing Form IDIP-011, client profile, the information required in (3)c., o. through t., v., and w.;

(5)  The client shall complete Form IDIP-019, consent for the release of confidential information, specifically for the department, the convicting court, and the department of safety, by including:

a.  The client’s name;

b.  The name and address of the convicting court; and

c.  The client’s dated signature;

(6)  The provider staff member shall sign and date Form IDIP-019, consent for the release of confidential information;

(7)  The client shall read and complete either Form IDIP-014, IDIP client agreement, or Form IDIP-015, WIDIP client agreement, by including:

a.  The client’s name; and

b.  The client’s dated signature, indicating that he or she has read the form and agrees to attend the identified sessions; and

(8)  The provider staff member shall complete either Form IDIP-014, IDIP client agreement, or Form IDIP-015, WIDIP client agreement, by including:

a.  The class location of the IDIP or WIDIP, including the street address, city or town, and telephone number;

b.  All scheduled session days, dates, times, and instructors; and

c.  The dated signature of the IDIP or WIDIP staff member.

     (d)  The client shall read, complete, and sign any other forms and materials that describe the provider’s individual IDIP or WIDIP policies and procedures or that offer other information related to the program.

What Happens During Your W/IDIP Intake Interview

You arrive at Amethyst Foundation in Epping at the appointed time with your required paperwork:
  • an original certified copy of your driving record, no older than 60 days, from New Hampshire, any state in which you hold a driver's license, and any state in which you've been arrested or convicted on a DWI/DUI
  • Your Department of Safety Notice Of Action indicating what program you are to take (i.e., IDIP)
  • Superior or district court orders
  • Chemical test results
If you forget any of these, or you attend an interview for the wrong program, you are rescheduled and charged an "administration fee" ($50 if IDIP, $100 if WIDIP, etc...).

You give these to the intake interviewer, who will be a LADC or, more likely, supervised staff member.

You then take two assessment exams; the RIASI (Research Institute on Addictions Self-Inventory) and DRI-II (Driver Risk Inventory-II).

The RIASI is the 1995 edition of the diagnostic instrument created by Thomas J. Nochasjski of the State University of New York that is specifically designed for DWI offenders.  I have posted the actual RIASI test you will take here.  You can see that the questions are pretty straightforward.  Be careful about the questions that seem to be asking about something else but are actually asking about your alcohol/drug use, stress coping, or agressiveness.  These are the nonobvious, subtle questions that I wrote about previously, here.

The DRI-II is the first edition, published in 1997, of the driving while impaired risk and needs assessment instrument created by Behavioral Data Systems, Ltd., which supposedly evaluates alcohol and other drug abuse, identifies driver aggressiveness, and measures stress coping abilities.  I do not have a copy of the DRI-II test, but the questions are very similar to those of the RIASI test.

Both tests are complete baloney and there is no scientific evidence at all that they are predictive for DUI/DWI reoffending.  Everyone, if they answer truthfully, will score as an alcoholic/drug addict on the RIASI.  The same is true for the DRI-II.  There are scientific papers showing the unreliability of the RIASI.  All but two of the studies done on the DRI-II, however, were conducted by Behavioral Data Systems, Ltd., the company that makes and sells it, so, of course, it works just smashingly.  The two non-BDS authored studies are severely flawed in methodology and are inconclusive.  Both the RIASI and DRI-II exams are garbage (I'll cover this topic in a later post).  But they are easy and cheap to administer, and give the appearance of being accurate and "scientific," so the state and recovery industry love them.

The DRI-II claims to measure "truthfulness" which you need to be very careful about.  I was completely honest when I took the DRI-II the first time, but I flunked the "truthfulness" component.

I really hate to advise anyone to do this, but I in this instance I have to.  LIE.  Lie on both exams.  You never drank or took drugs except for the night of the DUI/DWI.  For the DRI-II, you will take this again at the end of your assigned aftercare, so remember your lies, so that you can repeat them the second time you take it.  The DRI-II test compares the answers you give on the second administration to the the answers you gave on the first administration.  Just be consistent.  You are an angel who never took a drink or drug until your DUI/DWI...got it?  Good.

The people at Amethyst Foundation will do everything in their power to get you to be honest.  They will pretend to want to help you, or will suggest that there will be no consequences to your admissions.  Do not fool yourself.  They only want to get you to admit that you are an alcoholic or drug abuser and then punish you.

Why would they want to do that?

Because they are all former hardcore down and out alcoholics that have gone through AA.  They see everyone who gets arrested for a DUI/DWI as an alcoholic.  AA is a religious-based organization whose 10th and 12th steps mandate that members continue lifelong participation in the program and "carry this message to alcoholics and to practice these principles in all our affairs."  They see you as an "unfortunate" and want to save you.

And also because these are people who are angry at the world for their past and current problems and who have now been given some power.  You'll see that these are very spiteful, petty people.

So, in conclusion, lie on the RIASI and two administered DRI-II exams.  They are rigged against you.  Answer truthfully and you will be labelled an alcoholic or drug user by Amethyst and you can kiss your license goodbye for at least nine months while you attend AA meetings and pay for expensive weekly counseling sessions with a LADC (which are not covered by insurance).

Other Intake Paperwork

In addition to the assessment tests, you'll also have to fill out a bunch of paperwork, the most important of which is IDIP-019, the consent for release of confidential information, specifically for the Department of Health and Human Services, the convicting court, and the Department of Safety.  Once you sign this, be aware that anything you say or do from now on will not confidential and will be used against you.  Even statements made during aftercare AA meetings and individual LADC "counseling" sessions will be used against you (see the previous post for an outrageous example of this).  So be paranoid from this point onward.

Miscellaneous

I've been told that the intake interviewers will also take notes regarding your appearance, manners, punctuality, and anything else that might indicate alcohol or substance abuse.  Make sure you are clean (haircut, shave, use visine, mouthwash, etc...), dress well in ironed clothing, sit up straight, maintain eye contact, be calm, don't fidget, and be polite.  Do not smell of tobacco smoke (a symptom to them of an addictive personality) or alcohol.  Don't appear too intelligent.  They would probably love seeing some subtle indication that you are christian (jewelry, necklace?).

I doubt if my intake interviewer would have noticed, though.  (See below.)

My Intake

My intake was pretty routine.  It was performed by an old lady training to become a LADC.  She arrived almost a half-hour late, looked hungover in ragged clothing and uncombed/undyed hair, and shuffled, stumbled, and mumbled her way through the paperwork.  Multiple times I had to correct her instructions or redo the paperwork because of her confusion.  One of the Amethyst Foundation administrators (one of the few there that seems somewhat together) yelled at her several times, when she arrive late, and when she went to ask for help.  That wasn't bad--at least she wasn't one of the mean ones.  You'll meet those.

So, good luck.  Be paranoid.  Lie. Remember your lies so that you lie consistently (especially on the second DRI-II test).  Keep your mouth shut and incriminate yourself as little as possible.  Pretend you are stupid--they like that.

Please Tell Me Your Experiences With Amethyst Foundation, Inc.

Send Me Your Stories About Amethyst Foundation, Inc.

I would love to hear about people's experiences with Amethyst Foundation, Inc.  I know there must be many, many stories about this fraudulent operation.

Yet, there is no information on the web about Amethyst Foundation, Inc., at all.  Please pass your stories, good and bad, on to me and I will post them anonymously.

People deserve to know what they are getting into when they are ordered to go there.

Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s Financial Documents Look Shady

One measure of how honest a non-profit organization is, is how transparent it is.  Amethyst Foundation, Inc., is not very transparent, to put it mildly.  They seem to try as hard as possible to maintain as much secrecy as possible.  Their website is bare-bones with not a single name of anyone affiliated with it, only a general phone number and email address.  There are only five consumer reviews of it on the entire web.  If you've tried to find out anything about Amethyst Foundation, you'll know what I'm talking about.  It's quite a feat for any corporation to keep such a low profile, particularly a non-profit.  There's usually a reason for this.

For those, interested, I have located their IRS Form 990 filings for the fiscal years 2009, 2008, and 2007.  Federal law mandates that at least the last three years must be made publicly available.  Most non-profits provide more, but Amethyst Foundation supplies only the Federal minimum of three years.

Despite these 990 Forms being the most sparse, nondisclosing  I've ever seen, they tell quite a story.  For the last eight years, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., with its three tiny locations, has received over $1.2 million annually--99.5% from gifts, grants, contributions and membership fees (in other words exclusive, noncompetitive New Hampshire state contracts paid by the taxpayers).  Where does the $1.2 million go?  Total expenditures are reported to come to just under $1.2 million.  They are breaking even, right?  What an efficient non-profit!

Let's look closer:  There are two employees.  Bob Kelley, the Director, makes roughly $70k annually.  The Board of Directors work for nothing (really??).  There are no other key employees who are reported to earn any income.

"Office expenses" come to nearly $40,000(!)--I saw one old ink jet printer, some antique PCs, and a DVD player that doesn't work when I was there, and their documents look like the work of a high school student.

"Health Insurance" came to over $100,000, which is surprising given that there are only two employees.  Are all the contract part-time workers provided with health insurance?  I doubt that  At least I've never heard of such a thing.

"Utilities" came to almost $20,000!

Most of the rest of the expenditures fall into the amorphous categories of "other salaries and wages" (roughly $550,000 annually) and "all other expenses" (roughly $100,000).  Where is this $650k going to? There's no way of knowing.   They can't employ that many people.  It's impossible.  And LADCs, administrators, janitors, etc...don't make that much.  And the money's not going toward facilities--take a look at the dump that is Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s corporate headquarters in Epping, New Hampshire:
Amethyst Foundation gets a gift from New Hampshire tax  payers of $1.2 million yearly.  More than half of that disappears into the amorphous categories of "other salaries and wages" and "other expenditures."  Other amounts seem outrageously high.  They also sit  on nearly $700,000 of assets.  And remember, because Amethyst Corporation, Inc., is a IRS 501(c)(3) corporation, they are tax exempt.

When investigating non-profit organizations, one looks for the following trouble signs:
  • large end of year assets, which indicate hoarding;
  • vague categories (such as "other salary and wages") to inflate spending; and,
  • an overall lack of transparency.
Amethyst Foundation, Inc., exhibits all three.   Their end of year assets are huge--nearly equal to their total revenue, in fact.  They use very vague categories for most of their expenditures, suggesting that they might be inflating spending.  The specific categories appear at face value to be inflated (Office expenses, Health Insurance, Utilities).  And I refer to Amethyst Foundation, Inc., as the "Amethyst House of Mystery" because it is nearly completely lacking in transparency.  Just google it for yourself and see.

What a sweet deal Amethyst has going.  If they weren't so incompetent at what they do, and weren't such religious ideologues intent on forcing everyone into admitting they're "an alcoholic with an incurable disease" requiring months of AA attendance, it might even be somewhat moral.

Here are the IRS Form 990's that Amethyst Foundation filed for the last several years.  The 2007 form has information on it for several prior years.  The members of the Board of Directors are listed, too:



AA: Of Course It's a Cult!

 AA:  A Fascist Cult Founded On "God-Control"

On the blog "Positive Atheism," author Jack Trimpey has a great post entitled, "Alcoholics Anonymous:  Of Course It's a Cult."   Trimpey is the founder of the secular AA alternative, Rational Recovery.  He has been openly and aggressively critical of AA for decades.
Some examples of the many phone calls from across the country that Trimpey and Rational Recovery regarding AA include:

“I knew from the start there was something creepy about those people.”

“They aren’t of this world; they’re way out there.” 

Charles Manson
“I kind of got a shiver during one meeting when they were putting one guy down for arguing against the powerless concept.”

“When they said my family also was diseased, I knew something was wrong.”

“When they started this thing about anything being my Higher Power, it felt wrong, like it was going against something very important inside of me.” 
L. Ron Hubbard

“After I stopped going to meetings, no one I knew from the groups would have anything to do with me, even though I wasn’t drinking.”

“My brother quit drinking by going to AA, but he’s become so weird. I hardly know him any more, and almost miss the way he was when he was drinking. At least he was sincere, and could talk about something besides himself.” 
James Jones

“Our son went to a treatment specialist for drug addiction, and now he says we are satanic child molesters.”

“I’ve been telling my husband that the meetings aren’t helping, that he now calls his binges relapses and feels less guilty afterward. He admits he is drinking more and more often, but says relapse is a normal part of recovery. When he goes to meetings after a relapse, though, he feels ashamed and depressed.”

“A year after I quit drinking, my wife went to Al-Anon with a friend. Now she won’t communicate with me unless I go to AA.” 

Marshall Herff Applewhite
“The counselors at the treatment center were poorly-educated and acted like robots reciting every word.”

“I heard one man say, ‘I pray to God every day that I never get the idea that I can run my own life.’ When I heard this, I felt sick inside because I felt unable to leave the group.


It would be one thing if AA were actually effective, but it isn't.  It's recovery rate is a dismal 3-7%.  The spontaneous recovery rate for alcoholics who get no treatment is 5%.  Binge/relapse drinking for those in AA is nine times more likely to occur than for those who get no treatment.  The first of the twelve steps tells you that you must admit that you are powerless over alcohol.  The subsequent steps tell you to admit  your sins (defects) and that only God can cure you.  AA's method of learned helplessness is disastrous. 


Bill W.
Frank Buchman
Alcoholics Anonymous was formed by the Oxford Group in the 1930s.  The Oxford Group was founded by Frank Buchman, a Lutheran minister from Pennsylvania.  In one of Buchman's speeches during this period he stated:
     "The secret is God-control.  The only sane people in an insane world are those controlled by God.  God-controlled personalities make God-controlled nationalities.  This is the aim of the Oxford Group.
      The true patriot gives his life to bring his nation under God's control.  Those who oppose that control are public enemies....
     World peace will only come through nations which have achieved God-control.  And everybody can listen to God.  You can.  I can.  Everybody can have a part."
--Buchman, F., Remaking the World. London:  Blandford Press, 1961.

Buchman also said:
Adolph Hitler
"I thank heaven for a man like Adolph Hitler.  Human problems aren't economic. They're moral and they can't be solved by immoral measures. They could be solved within a God-controlled democracy, or perhaps I should say a theocracy, and they could be solved through a God-controlled Fascist dictatorship."



 --Birnie, W.A.H., "Hitler or Any Fascist Leader Controlled by God Could Cure All Ills of World," Buchman Believes.  New York World-Telegram, Aug 26 (1936).  cited from Thornton-Duesbury, J.P., The Open Secret of MRA:  An examination of Mr. Driberg's 'critical examination' of Moral Re-Armament."  London:  Blandford Press, 1964.  Also available here. 

Ask any AA member about their group's origins and the Oxford Group and watch what happens.  They'll get incredibly defensive and start rationalizing.  Then suggest that perhaps they, and not you, might be the ones in denial.

The Amethyst House of Mystery

State-mandated rehab for DUI offenders is a huge business.  These very profitable nonprofits lobby for, and receive huge amounts of taxpayer funding. They are virtually unregulated and unrestrained, and it's all perfectly legal.  In fact, it's condoned, all in the name of saving the poor victims of the "disease" called alcoholism.  These are the gateways to the coerced recovery industry--an industry that is largely blind to science and which makes billions of dollars a year, lining the pockets of mostly uneducated "experts such as "Licensed/certified Alcohol and Drug Counselors" (LADCs or CADCs) whose only required formal training for certification is a GED/High School diploma, 270 hours of classes or "training", and supervised "experience" (which can include filing and record keeping).

I'll post about these LADCs later, but I found them to be hardcore AA true believers:  all former alcoholics and fundamentalist Christians who believe alcoholism is a disease.  All DUI offenders suffer from this disease and the only cure is finding god (their god, the Christian one), praying, and following the twelve steps.  They are anti-intellectual, anti-science, intolerant and threatened by skepticism.  They drip with condescension, righteousness, stupidity, and anger.  They finally have some power (by the state and courts) and they validate their beliefs by breaking you and converting you to their religion (AA).  It is important for them to do this because their beliefs are all that they have.  They bottomed-out as drunks and drug-abusers, lost everything (including their dignity and self-respect), and rebuilt their entire psyches on the beliefs espoused by Christian Fundamentalism and A.A.  They are dangerous.

I'm sure a lot of people reading this think I have an axe to grind.  I do.  Not about being punished for my DUI.  I fully realize the danger I caused to society and understand I need to be either punished and/or rehabilitated.  The axe that I want to grind is being forced into a system of people like I describe in the paragraph above. 

Anyway, I diverge.  Let me tell you about the mysterious and very profitable New Hampshire court-mandated rehab industry:

One of the largest of these rehab corporations, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., happens to be the one I went to, here in the "live free or die" state.  All of this was a huge eye-opener to me, and it took a huge amount of digging to learn about it.  I suspect Amethyst Foundtion, Inc., and others corporations like it, are all making a great effort to keep a low profile.  (I can only imagine digging up the dirt on the larger topic of privatized correctional facilities, where drug rehab and AA are also deeply entrenched.)

So, I received the standard 1st offense D.U.I. sentence in New Hampshire:  a six month Administrative License Suspension and a nine month Criminal Court License Suspension, to run concurrently.  My nine month Criminal Court License Suspension was to be reduced to a three month suspension on the condition that I complete an Intoxicated Driver Intervention Program (IDIP) at a facility closest to my residence.

That sounded good to me.  I knew I wasn't an alcoholic.  The night of my DUI was the first time I had more than 2-3 drinks in the last six years.  I've gone weeks without any alcohol at all and didn't give a second thought of it.  Surely, I'd just quietly complete the IDIP program, and get my driving privileges back in six months.  I knew of friends that had gone through similar programs in other states and who had no problems.

According to Administrative Rule He-A 704 (based on Statutory Authority:  RSA 265-A:39), I had to take the IDIP classes at the facility closest to my residence or place of work.  The classes cost $460 and were held two nights a week for six weeks.  The facility was "Amethyst House" in Epping, NH.

I tried to learn more about Amethyst House.  All I could find on-line was a single stripped down website for Amethyst Foundation, Inc.  An address, contact info, description of the IDIP program, forms and photos were there.  What was strange was that there was no directory or any names listed.  I tried calling the phone number multiple times throughout the day, but always got a busy signal.  At 5:01 PM sharp no one picked up the phone.

Judging from the photographs on its website, the place looked like a dump:

I decided to do some investigating.

The Hoover's Business Directory listed Amethyst Foundation, Inc., and the name of two executives, Director Bob Kelley and Ellen Parker.  Apparently Amethyst has locations throughout the state; Salem, Portsmouth, Hanover, Claremont, and Epping.  Its Certificate of Revival of Incorporation, naming the Board of Directors and Officers, and place of business (Epping, NH) may be found here.

According to public financial records available at this site, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., of Epping, NH (Employee Identification Number 020363792), is a 509(a)(2) charitable organization whose activities include rehabilitating alcoholics, drug abusers, compulsive gamblers, etc...  It was ruled a 509(a)(2) nonprofit organization by the IRS in 04/1987.  For the tax year of 2006, they held $778,642 in assets and had an income of $1,134,922.  Organizations performing similar types of work, on average, held only $311,304 in assets and had incomes of $610,576.  According to this site, there are only 42 other 509(a)(2) organizations performing similar activities in the country.  Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) is one, and is ranked as having the highest income for this tax period, at a whopping $41,775,641.  Amethyst Foundation, Inc., is ranked as the fifth at $1,134,922.

Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s income for the fiscal year 2010 was $1,134,922, as indicated by their IRS Form 900.  On this form, the organization's stated mission was: 
"To disseminate information concerning the effects on human beings of ingesting ethyl alcohol and other drugs; to assist individuals in assessing their own personal relationships with alcohol; to identify those individuals with drinking problems and involve them in a[n] alcohol awareness school--the organization operates a court and state mandated school for driving while under the influence of alcohol."
A search of the public records indicates that the state of New Hampshire contracts with Amethyst Foundation, Inc., for significant amounts of money.  For the period from July 1, 2010 to June 30, 2011, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., along with two other 509(a)(2) organizations, Serenity Place and Tri-County Community Action Program, shared $751,400 in tax payer money in the form of sole source contracts (one contract for $455,000 and one for $296,400).  Amethyst Foundation, Inc., has a registered lobbyist with the New Hampshire Legislature, Edward DuPont.  He's doing a very good job.  For one year, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., shared nearly one million dollars in sole source contract money--money provided by New Hampshire residents.

And because of Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s IRS 509(a)(2) status, all of this income is tax free!  

I thought my IDIP program was expensive until I saw the prices for others offered by Amethyst Foundation:

Phase II (for 2nd Offenders), a seven day residential program......$1,550.00 
.....of which Amethyst keeps $1,300.00.
WIDIP ("Weekend Intoxicated Driver Intervention Program").........$585.00 
.....of which Amethyst keeps $485.00.
MOP ("Multiple Offender Program")...........................................$1,550.00
.....of which Amethyst keeps $1,300.00.

Of the $460 fee for the IDIP class, Amethyst keeps $410.

The state of New Hampshire gets the crumbs as administrative fees.

Amethyst Foundation does a big business, as I was later to find out.  The classes filled up quickly.  A lot of the "customers" were from out of state.  In fact, a LADC told me many are celebrities.  I was told Amethyst Foundation was the only residential facility in New England.

So, we have a nice, very profitable, "non profit" corporation that pays no taxes and receives a huge amount of taxpayer funds.  How much they charge is determined, not by the market, but by the New Hampshire legislature.  They do a huge business and, with ever stricter DUI laws, will never lack for customers.  What a sweet deal.

After Your D.U.I. Arrest--Part II

If you refused your B.A.C. test, or consented and had a B.A.C. level at or above 0.08 g Ethanol/100 ml, you've received an Administrative License Suspension.  This suspension was anywhere from 180 days to 2 years, depending upon your driving record.  If you refused your B.A.C. test, any criminal suspension will run consecutively.  If you consented, any criminal suspension will run concurrently.  Additionally, criminal court judges will likely impose a stiffer sentence on someone who refused a B.A.C. test.

Given this, why would anyone refuse a BAC test?  Findings by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) show that those who refused received higher fines and longer jail terms.  New Hampshire residents refused more than any other state's drivers: Almost one-quarter (22.4 percent) who were arrested refused to submit to a BAC test.  I have no idea why New Hampshire residents show such poor legal judgment.

There are four possible DWI/DUI charges.  Which one you are charged with, and the penalty, will be indicated on your Complaint. The most basic charge, DUI, is classified as a class B misdemeanor and a crime. Although you cannot go to jail for a simple first-offense DUI conviction, both DUI 2nd offense and aggravated DUI each carry the possibility of a year in jail. If you are charged with felony aggravated DUI based on serious bodily injury (including to yourself), you face up to seven years in prison; a fourth-offense DUI is also a felony.

A regular, first-offense DUI conviction is punishable by a fine of between $500.00 and $1,200.00, plus a standard penalty assessment of 20% of the amount of the fine, and a mandatory minimum license loss of ninety days, with a maximum loss of two years. The minimum license loss that the Court may impose is nine months, but six months of that period may be suspended by the Court if you enter into a mandatory alcohol treatment program within forty-five days of the date of your conviction.

In certain unusual circumstance such as having a prior DUI on your record within the last ten years (even though you are not formally charged with DUI, 2nd offense), you face substantially higher minimum penalties plus a seven-day residential treatment program. If you are under twenty-one years of age at the time of the offense, you face a minimum revocation of one year, and if you are under twenty, in addition to the one year minimum imposed by the Court, you face and additional loss that can vary from twenty to ninety days, depending on your prior record.

Upon conviction of any DUI offense, you also must complete a state-approved DUI training course prior to restoration of your license or operating privilege. For a first offense DUI, you must attend and complete a state-approved 20-hour program and any recommended aftercare, including attendance at AA and/or further alcohol treatment. Some of these programs meet in the evening, some on weekends.  This state-approved program is called an Impaired Driver Intervention Program, or IDIP.

Again, if this is your first DUI offense, and you complete an IDIP program, your criminal court license suspension will be reduced from nine months to three months...in theory.  It turns out that though the IDIP  program is only 20 hours, the aftercare that is assigned usually ends up being longer than the original nine month non-reduced suspension.

Oh, and you'll end up paying $460 for the IDIP program and hundreds for assigned aftercare.

My next post will be about the Alcohol Treatment Centers that run IDIP programs.  The people who run them are, in general, stupid, incompetent, former alcoholics, now turned fundamentalist Christians via Alcoholics Anonymous.  They will teach you that you are powerless to your disease of alcoholism and that the only cure is through God.  

Welcome my friend, welcome to the machine.

After Your D.U.I. Arrest--What Happens Now?

You've been arrested for D.U.I.   What happens now?  A New Hampshire DUI is defined as two separate actions against you; a civil matter handled with the NH DMV (an administrative matter, really), and a criminal matter handled in the New Hampshire court system

Upon being released on bail, should you be that fortunate, you'll be given a yellow Defendant's copy of "The State of New Hampshire Judicial Branch Orders and Condition of Bail" or a "Bail Receipt."  At the top will be "State v. your name here." Yes, that's right, the plaintiff is the State, which represents the will of the majority of its residents. This form is also called a NHJB-2369 form, as indicated on the lower left corner in very fine print. On the second page of this form you will be told when and where your arraignment (scheduled court appearance) will be.  Alternatively, you will be informed of your arraignment date on a summons or complaint.  Your arraignment date is usually a couple months later.  You will also likely be told on the form to refrain from consuming alcohol. There will also be a Bail Commissioner's fee.

You will now have to get your impounded car back. In my case, it cost me nearly $500. Yes, that's right. Towing cost $200, "mileage" was $100, and "storage" was $200. I was just thankful to get my car back undamaged and without anything missing from it.

Enjoy your driving privileges while they last.  You might at this time start to become familiar with New Hampshire Criminal and Administrative Law.  It is important to begin to understand the complex legal labyrinth that you have entered.  If not you will be helpless.  You will need to read New Hampshire Revised Statutes Annotated (RSA) 265-A Alcohol and Drug Impairment, and the New Hampshire Code of Administrative Rules He-A 300, Saf-C 2800, and Saf-C 200. 

If you submitted to a post-arrest breath test, you undoubtedly already know your test result. The official result of your breath test appears on the pink Intoxilyzer 5000 Test Record that should have been given to you by the police prior to your release from custody. The official result is the number that appears to the right of "REPORTED VALUE."  Upon release from custody, your license will be taken and you will be issued a Temporary Driving Permit, which will expire thirty days from date of service.

If you submitted to a blood test, you will be notified by certified mail of the results of that test by means of a letter from the State of New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services forwarded to you by the law enforcement agency that arrested you. It make take four to eight weeks, or more, for you to receive the results of your blood test, even longer if the police ask that your sample be tested for controlled drugs.  Upon release from custody, you will retain your license, but upon notice of results of an illegal B.A.C. you will be asked to immediately surrender it to the Department of Motor Vehicles.

If you refused to submit to a post-arrest chemical test requested by the police, the police will immediately take your license away and issue you a thirty day Temporary Driving Permit. You will also face an automatic Administrative License Suspension by the State of New Hampshire. The period of revocation is 180 days if your motor vehicle records show no prior convictions and no prior Administrative License Suspensions; if you have either, the revocation period becomes two years. By operation of New Hampshire law, this period of revocation cannot run at the same time as any other loss, meaning that your administrative license loss will be consecutive with any other New Hampshire suspension, including any loss you may receive in court if convicted of the underlying DWI charge.

During this time, the state prosecutor will be assembling all the evidence for its case against you: the B.A.C. determination, the police cruiser tapes, the police reports, etc... You, or your lawyer, may make a discovery request to obtain these before the day of your court appearance.

Next, you will receive the first of many letters from the State of New Hampshire Department of Safety, Division of Motor Vehicles. This first letter will state that:
"as a result of receiving a sworn report from a law enforcement officer alleging you submitted to a chemical test(s) that disclosed a drug/alcohol concentration in your system that met or exceeded the legal limit

all license/operating privileges are suspended/revoked for X months."
If you either refused to submit to a chemical test, or you submitted to one and it showed an alcohol concentration of .08 or more (.02 or more if you are under age 21), you face the loss of your New Hampshire driver's license or right to operate in New Hampshire under the Administrative License Suspension law (ALS). That loss may be for six months or two years, depending on your motor vehicle record.  My ALS was for nine months because I had four points on my driving record during the last three years (three points for a speeding ticket going 16-20 mph over the speeding limit, and one point for an expired inspection sticker).

If you submitted to a chemical test, the period of revocation will run at the same time as any other loss, meaning that your administrative license loss will be concurrent with any other New Hampshire suspension, including any loss you may receive in court if convicted of the underlying D.U.I. charge.  If you refused to submit to a chemical test, this period of revocation cannot run at the same time as any other loss, meaning that your administrative license loss will be consecutive with any other New Hampshire suspension.

After surrendering your license, you cannot drive. If you are caught driving you will be sentenced to 7 days in jail and an additional one year suspension/revocation of your license/operating privileges.

You may, in writing, request an administrative license suspension hearing within 30 days of your arrest if you refused a B.A.C. test or blew an illegal B.A.C., or within 30 days of receiving your Notice of Suspension from the Department of Safety/Motor Vehicles if you submitted to a blood test. It's difficult to prevail in these, though. The state (law enforcement)has the burden of proof by a preponderance of evidence that:

1. the officer had reasonable grounds to pull you over;
2. the facts on which the reasonable grounds were based;
3. that you were arrested properly;
4. that you either refused a B.A.C. test, or consented and were above .08;
5. that the officer advised you that refusal to the B.A.C. test would result in suspension of your license.

"Preponderance of the evidence" simply means "more likely than not." It is the lowest standard of proof.

If you decide to go for the hearing, you will definitely need an attorney, which will be expensive.

Next, your criminal court appearance. Yes...unfortunately, there's a lot more to come.

Your D.U.I. Arrest

Let's assume that you've had a couple beers, you've gotten into your car and drive off.  Under what circumstances may a police officer pull you over?   The answer is "most."

The Stop

All the officer needs is "reasonable suspicion" of criminal activity, such as speeding or a tail light out, going too slow, illegal start and stop, a call from a cell phone informant that observed the alleged driving in an erratic manner, roadblocks, cars pulled over from an accident or that have driven off the road in snowy conditions, or even those parked in a lot or on the shoulder of the road.  Reasonable suspicion is very broad.  Judges or juries just need to believe that the officer was reasonable and not acting irrationally or with ulterior motives.

Without pulling a car over, the authorities are permitted to run a check with the Registry of Motor Vehicles. If they find that the owner has a suspended license they have established reasonable suspicion to complete an investigatory stop.

Reasonable suspicion is not a high threshold, but it does have limits.  The Supreme Court has said that it must be based on "specific and articulable facts", "taken together with rational inferences from those facts" (Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. at 21), but it must consist of  more than an "inchoate and unparticularized suspicion or 'hunch' " (Id., at 27).

There are also three categories of exceptions police can use to avoid the need for reasonable suspicion entirely. 

One such exception is the “Community Caretaking Doctrine”.  The Community Caretaking Doctrine takes place to make sure the occupants of a car are safe, such as checking on a car pulled over on a road shoulder with a flat tire.  This exception can't be premised where the real intent is to investigate potential criminal activity.

A second, the “Emergency Exception Doctrine,” permits the apprehension of suspects where there appears to be an emergency situation requiring immediate action for the protection of life, property and safety of the public.

And, thirdly, of course, there are the very controversial sobriety check points.

Not everyone arrested for a DUI is a drunk who is grossly impaired. In New Hampshire it is illegal to drive with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08 percent or above. The .08 limit is the standard measurement used across the United States for the "impaired" driver. That can be a little as two drinks.  New Hampshire has lower BAC limits for drivers of commercial vehicles and drivers under the age of 21. In addition to alcohol the New Hampshire DUI law also includes driving under the influence of controlled substances such as marijuana, cocaine and other drugs.  Even prescription drugs taken under the direction of your physician are not exempt.  The officer will use reasonable cause to pull you over and conduct a road-side sobriety test and perform a BAC test.  Even if your BAC is within legal limits, if, in the officer's opinion, you appear impaired, you will likely be arrested.

Yes, there are quite a lot of traffic fatalities that involve alcohol, but not as many as groups like MADD (and their over-the-top emotional ads) would have you think. According to former MADD President Wendy Hamilton, there were 17,448 drunken driving deaths in 2001, up from 16,572 in 1999. An analysis by Edward Hass shows this is simply is not true. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, there were 17,448 alcohol-related traffic fatalities in 2001, but they were not all the result of drunk driving as Hamilton claims. The NHTSA defines a fatal traffic crash as being alcohol-related if either a driver or a non-occupant (e.g., pedestrian) has a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.01 grams per deciliter (g/dl) or greater in a police-reported traffic crash. To put 0.01 g/dl in perspective, ten times that amount is required to achieve a BAC of 0.10 g/dl, which is the legal limit of intoxication in most states. Yet MADD continues to mislead America by allowing the public to believe that there were 17,448 victims of drunk drivers in 2001.  And it is almost entirely due to MADD that we have the current, very strict and very punitive, D.U.I. laws that create a large influx of offenders into our prisons and leave predominantly young people with criminal records that will follow them for the rest of their lives.  I will have a lot to say about D.U.I. legislation and MADD in later posts.  I, and others, see the push for zero tolerance of drinking and driving, particularly among teenage drivers, as another form of prohibition.

Can and should you refuse a BAC test?  You waived that right when you got your license.  New Hampshire, like all other States, is what's called an “implied consent” state.  This means that the mere ownership of a drivers license gives a law enforcement officer implied consent to conduct blood-alcohol tests if the officer believes you may be under the influence (through, for instance, the use of field sobriety tests). In implied consent states, if you refuse to take a blood-alcohol tests, you have your driving privileges taken away automatically, regardless of whether you are intoxicated.  Furthermore, the 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination does not apply to blood-alcohol tests, so you must consent if asked (or face a driver’s license suspension).  Indeed, a study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) showed that those who refused received higher fines and longer jail terms.

If you believe your stop and/or arrest was illegal, you can hire an attorney (which will be very expensive) and try your luck in NH Superior Court.  Several cases are summarized on this NH Dept of Safety site.   The arresting officer report will certainly make you out to appear very impaired and you're going to have to show he had no reasonable grounds.  Succeeding in an illegal stop/arrest hearing is not very likely.  Furthermore, the requisite legal representation will be expensive.

In short, it is very expensive and unlikely that you will prevail in contesting most D.U.I. stops and arrests.  The best strategy might be to plead guilty, move forward, and get your license back as soon as possible.

The Arrest

So at this point you've been stopped by a police officer with (arguable) reasonable suspicion to investigate. You took a turn too wide, your headlights are off, another driver reported you using their cell phone, there is an accident (not necessarily involving you) or emergency, etc...When he/she starts to grill you do not admit to having had anything to drink. Instead, ask him/her is you are under arrest for any crime, and, if not, could you please get on your way.  The police are not your friend.  Anything you say will be used against you.  Be polite, but firm.  Do not make any incriminating statements.  Police officers often pull the line, "if you're straight with me, I'll give you a break."  No. They won't give you any breaks at all.  They will use any and all evidence to nail your sorry ass.  That's their job.  (For a great video on what to do and what not to do during a police stop see FlexYourRights.org's "BUSTED:  The Citizen's Guide to Surviving Police Encounters.")

The Officer will be looking for probable cause to arrest you for being impaired, such as:
  • odor of an alcoholic beverage on the driver's breath or in the car generally
  • slurred speech in response to the questioning
  • watery, blood shot, and/or reddish eyes
  • flushed face
  • droopy eyelids
  • difficulty in understanding and responding intelligently to question
  • fumbling with his or her driver's license and registration
  • the plain-view presence of containers of alcoholic beverages in the vehicle.
  • admission of consumption of alcoholic beverage
If the officer sees any of the above you will be asked to get out of the car and perform a field sobriety test (FST).  A 3-task battery of standardized field sobriety tests (SFSTs) is gradually being adopted by all states. They were recommended by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) after studies indicated other FSTs were relatively unreliable. The NHTSA-approved battery of tests consists of the horizontal gaze nystagmus test, the walk-and-turn test, and the one-leg-stand.  This is what is used in New Hampshire.

If you fail the SFST, you will be asked to do a test for your Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) either by Breathalyzer or by a Blood draw.  In all U.S. States, including New Hampshire, Driving Licensing law include implied consent to have a breath or blood sample taken for B.A.C. determination.  If you refuse, your license will be automatically be revoked (you agreed to "implied consent" when you got your license).  In additional, judges statistically impose stricter sentences on those who refuse BAC tests.

If your behavior, SFST, and BAC test, provide probable cause, you will be read your Miranda Rights and arrested.

Keep in mind the difference in the burdens of evidence.  Reasonable suspicion is needed for the officer to stop and investigate.  Probable cause is needed to arrest you.  Reasonable suspicion requires less evidence than probable cause, but more than a mere hunch. A rule of thumb is that reasonable suspicion requires 25 % proof, and probable cause requires more than 50 % statistical chance.  Therefore, if there is probable cause for arrest for DWI, as suggested by the research and examples used above, then there is reasonable suspicion to stop a driver.

Next time--going to court and getting criminal and administrative suspension of your license.

The Purpose of this Blog

I'm writing this blog for several reasons.

The first, and most important, is to voice my outrage at being forced by the State of New Hampshire to practice a religion I don't believe in.  I was arrested and pleaded guilty to a DUI. in 2010.  It was wrong, I am very sorry, and I am willing to go through a reasonable punitive and rehabilitative process.  However, as a U.S. citizen, I should not be subject to a process run by evangelicals or forced to practice religion.  I, like thousands of other New Hampshire residents found guilty of DUI, am being forced to complete State-sponsored Impaired Driver Intervention Programs (IDIPs), see Licensed Alcohol and Drug Counselors (LADCs), and attend Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) meetings for up to a year.  Everyone I've encountered in this process is a former alcoholic and true believer in AA.  Because the people in charge of making the determination of whether or not I've been rehabilitated are AA evangelicals, I have to pretend that I'm "with the program" in order to get my driving license back.  This involves repenting and praying at AA meetings, and lying about my religious beliefs to my LADC who I must report to weekly for "therapy."  For any State to do this is a blatant violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, and abhorrent to the values on which this country was founded.  Moreover, as a citizen, I resent my tax money being used to line the pockets of these organizations.

A second reason is to reveal the ineffectiveness and the religious/cult-ish nature of the twelve-step recovery movement, Alcoholics Anonymous.  These recovery programs have been repeatedly and unanimously adjudged by the courts to be religious in nature.  They have been proven by repeated, rigorous scientific studies to be ineffective, or worse.  Real alcoholics need to be properly diagnosed and treated.  Our current court-mandated programs see everyone as an alcoholic and prescribe treatment that is ineffective.

A third reason is to criticize the irrationality of religion in general, and to write about religious groups constant attempts to violate our First Amendment guarantees of being free from "the establishment of any law respecting religion."  I don't care what idiotic God you worship (Xenu, The Flying Spaghetti Monster, Jehovah, Jesus) just don't force me to, okay?  That's not too much to ask, is it?

A fourth reason is to tell my story and provide others with realistic expectations of the consequences of a DUI arrest and conviction.  Roughly 5,000 people a year are arrested for DUI in New Hampshire, whose total population is only 1.3 million.  If you drink and drive, or legally take medication and drive, it is highly probable that you will be arrested for DUI.  In addition, New Hampshire has some of the harshest penalties.  You or someone you know will likely be arrested for DUI  I want you to know what you are in for in you've been arrested, or scare you if you haven't yet been arrested and drink and drive.

I was unaware of the full consequences of a DUI conviction.  I entered into this process largely blind.  My experience has been a series of one surprise after another.  I still haven't gotten my license back, and I'm not sure when I will.  This has been a long, frustrating, expensive and cryptic experience.  Though the law is unambiguous, the administrative procedure is riddled with hidden traps.  The administrative portion of the DUI requires subjective determinations of your progress through the rehabilitation process.  Christian fundamentalist AA true-believers will be making these determinations.  You will need to know what they want to hear.

A fifth reason is to chronicle the abuse of authority I and others have witnessed by the administrators of the Impaired Driver Intervention Programs.  Administrators, working through very profitable organizations like Amethyst Foundation, Inc., routinely punish DUI offenders for vagaries such as "complaining" and "noncompliance" by withholding their driving privileges for over a year or more, while forcing them to attend AA meetings and LADC counseling sessions.  These administrators feel compelled to inflict as much pain as possible, and are virtually unaccountable to anyone.

There is very little information on the web about this.  The laws, administrative rules and regulations are there, but there is nothing about what you will actually go through.  I wish there had been something there for me when I needed it.  I hope this blog helps someone in a similar situation.  Good luck.

A final reason for my creating this blog is to maintain my sanity.  I'm being forced to attend AA meetings where people pray, chant in unison, make undignified public confessions, deny reality and reason, talk about their religious conversion and salvation, and pressure others to behave similarly.   The duration of my license suspension depends upon whether I am deemed "rehabilitated."  The people who make this determination are former drunks who are now gung-ho AA members:  Licensed Alcohol and Drug Counselors (LADCs), LADC-in-training, and others involved in the New Hampshire recovery system.  They believe one drink makes you an "alcoholic"--someone with a life-long, incurable, progressive disease that only lifelong AA attendance and religious conversion will prevent you from dying from.  They are spiteful, bitter, stupid people, who, now given some power and acknowledgement for probably the first time in their life, now desire to force their will on others and hurt them.  My privilege to drive--to work, to mandated AA and counseling sessions, to the grocery store, to the drug store, to medical providers, etc...--in a rural area with no public transportation or affordable private transportation, is at the mercy of fervent, religious fundamentalists who want to repeatedly destroy my dignity to bolster their own damaged self-esteem.

(A standard, boilerplate, legal disclaimer up front.  None of what I write in this blog should be construed as legal advice.  I make no claims, promises or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the information contained here.  The law changes very rapidly and, accordingly, I do not guarantee that any information on this blog or is accurate and up to date. Additionally, the law differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and is subject to interpretation of courts located in each county. Legal advice must be tailored to the specific circumstances of each case and the tools and information provided to you may not be an appropriate fit in your case. Nothing that you read or is provided on this web site should be used as a substitute for the advice of competent legal counsel.)