AA: Of Course It's a Cult!

 AA:  A Fascist Cult Founded On "God-Control"

On the blog "Positive Atheism," author Jack Trimpey has a great post entitled, "Alcoholics Anonymous:  Of Course It's a Cult."   Trimpey is the founder of the secular AA alternative, Rational Recovery.  He has been openly and aggressively critical of AA for decades.

Some examples of the many phone calls from across the country that Trimpey and Rational Recovery regarding AA include:

“I knew from the start there was something creepy about those people.”

“They aren’t of this world; they’re way out there.” 

Charles Manson

“I kind of got a shiver during one meeting when they were putting one guy down for arguing against the powerless concept.”

“When they said my family also was diseased, I knew something was wrong.”

“When they started this thing about anything being my Higher Power, it felt wrong, like it was going against something very important inside of me.” 

L. Ron Hubbard

“After I stopped going to meetings, no one I knew from the groups would have anything to do with me, even though I wasn’t drinking.”

“My brother quit drinking by going to AA, but he’s become so weird. I hardly know him any more, and almost miss the way he was when he was drinking. At least he was sincere, and could talk about something besides himself.” 

James Jones

“Our son went to a treatment specialist for drug addiction, and now he says we are satanic child molesters.”

“I’ve been telling my husband that the meetings aren’t helping, that he now calls his binges relapses and feels less guilty afterward. He admits he is drinking more and more often, but says relapse is a normal part of recovery. When he goes to meetings after a relapse, though, he feels ashamed and depressed.”

“A year after I quit drinking, my wife went to Al-Anon with a friend. Now she won’t communicate with me unless I go to AA.” 

Marshall Herff Applewhite

“The counselors at the treatment center were poorly-educated and acted like robots reciting every word.”

“I heard one man say, ‘I pray to God every day that I never get the idea that I can run my own life.’ When I heard this, I felt sick inside because I felt unable to leave the group.

It would be one thing if AA were actually effective, but it isn't.  It's recovery rate is a dismal 3-7%.  The spontaneous recovery rate for alcoholics who get no treatment is 5%.  Binge/relapse drinking for those in AA is nine times more likely to occur than for those who get no treatment.  The first of the twelve steps tells you that you must admit that you are powerless over alcohol.  The subsequent steps tell you to admit  your sins (defects) and that only God can cure you.  AA's method of learned helplessness is disastrous. 

Bill W.

Frank Buchman

Alcoholics Anonymous was formed by the Oxford Group in the 1930s.  The Oxford Group was founded by Frank Buchman, a Lutheran minister from Pennsylvania.  In one of Buchman's speeches during this period he stated:

     "The secret is God-control.  The only sane people in an insane world are those controlled by God.  God-controlled personalities make God-controlled nationalities.  This is the aim of the Oxford Group.
      The true patriot gives his life to bring his nation under God's control.  Those who oppose that control are public enemies....
     World peace will only come through nations which have achieved God-control.  And everybody can listen to God.  You can.  I can.  Everybody can have a part."

--Buchman, F., Remaking the World. London:  Blandford Press, 1961.

Buchman also said:

Adolph Hitler

"I thank heaven for a man like Adolph Hitler.  Human problems aren't economic. They're moral and they can't be solved by immoral measures. They could be solved within a God-controlled democracy, or perhaps I should say a theocracy, and they could be solved through a God-controlled Fascist dictatorship."

 --Birnie, W.A.H., "Hitler or Any Fascist Leader Controlled by God Could Cure All Ills of World," Buchman Believes.  New York World-Telegram, Aug 26 (1936).  cited from Thornton-Duesbury, J.P., The Open Secret of MRA:  An examination of Mr. Driberg's 'critical examination' of Moral Re-Armament."  London:  Blandford Press, 1964.  Also available here. 

Ask any AA member about their group's origins and the Oxford Group and watch what happens.  They'll get incredibly defensive and start rationalizing.  Then suggest that perhaps they, and not you, might be the ones in denial.

The Amethyst House of Mystery

State-mandated rehab for DUI offenders is a huge business.  These very profitable nonprofits lobby for, and receive huge amounts of taxpayer funding. They are virtually unregulated and unrestrained, and it's all perfectly legal.  In fact, it's condoned, all in the name of saving the poor victims of the "disease" called alcoholism.  These are the gateways to the coerced recovery industry--an industry that is largely blind to science and which makes billions of dollars a year, lining the pockets of mostly uneducated "experts such as "Licensed/certified Alcohol and Drug Counselors" (LADCs or CADCs) whose only required formal training for certification is a GED/High School diploma, 270 hours of classes or "training", and supervised "experience" (which can include filing and record keeping).

I'll post about these LADCs later, but I found them to be hardcore AA true believers:  all former alcoholics and fundamentalist Christians who believe alcoholism is a disease.  All DUI offenders suffer from this disease and the only cure is finding god (their god, the Christian one), praying, and following the twelve steps.  They are anti-intellectual, anti-science, intolerant and threatened by skepticism.  They drip with condescension, righteousness, stupidity, and anger.  They finally have some power (by the state and courts) and they validate their beliefs by breaking you and converting you to their religion (AA).  It is important for them to do this because their beliefs are all that they have.  They bottomed-out as drunks and drug-abusers, lost everything (including their dignity and self-respect), and rebuilt their entire psyches on the beliefs espoused by Christian Fundamentalism and A.A.  They are dangerous.

I'm sure a lot of people reading this think I have an axe to grind.  I do.  Not about being punished for my DUI.  I fully realize the danger I caused to society and understand I need to be either punished and/or rehabilitated.  The axe that I want to grind is being forced into a system of people like I describe in the paragraph above. 

Anyway, I diverge.  Let me tell you about the mysterious and very profitable New Hampshire court-mandated rehab industry:

One of the largest of these rehab corporations, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., happens to be the one I went to, here in the "live free or die" state.  All of this was a huge eye-opener to me, and it took a huge amount of digging to learn about it.  I suspect Amethyst Foundtion, Inc., and others corporations like it, are all making a great effort to keep a low profile.  (I can only imagine digging up the dirt on the larger topic of privatized correctional facilities, where drug rehab and AA are also deeply entrenched.)

So, I received the standard 1st offense D.U.I. sentence in New Hampshire:  a six month Administrative License Suspension and a nine month Criminal Court License Suspension, to run concurrently.  My nine month Criminal Court License Suspension was to be reduced to a three month suspension on the condition that I complete an Intoxicated Driver Intervention Program (IDIP) at a facility closest to my residence.

That sounded good to me.  I knew I wasn't an alcoholic.  The night of my DUI was the first time I had more than 2-3 drinks in the last six years.  I've gone weeks without any alcohol at all and didn't give a second thought of it.  Surely, I'd just quietly complete the IDIP program, and get my driving privileges back in six months.  I knew of friends that had gone through similar programs in other states and who had no problems.

According to Administrative Rule He-A 704 (based on Statutory Authority:  RSA 265-A:39), I had to take the IDIP classes at the facility closest to my residence or place of work.  The classes cost $460 and were held two nights a week for six weeks.  The facility was "Amethyst House" in Epping, NH.

I tried to learn more about Amethyst House.  All I could find on-line was a single stripped down website for Amethyst Foundation, Inc.  An address, contact info, description of the IDIP program, forms and photos were there.  What was strange was that there was no directory or any names listed.  I tried calling the phone number multiple times throughout the day, but always got a busy signal.  At 5:01 PM sharp no one picked up the phone.

Judging from the photographs on its website, the place looked like a dump:

I decided to do some investigating.

The Hoover's Business Directory listed Amethyst Foundation, Inc., and the name of two executives, Director Bob Kelley and Ellen Parker.  Apparently Amethyst has locations throughout the state; Salem, Portsmouth, Hanover, Claremont, and Epping.  Its Certificate of Revival of Incorporation, naming the Board of Directors and Officers, and place of business (Epping, NH) may be found here.

According to public financial records available at this site, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., of Epping, NH (Employee Identification Number 020363792), is a 509(a)(2) charitable organization whose activities include rehabilitating alcoholics, drug abusers, compulsive gamblers, etc...  It was ruled a 509(a)(2) nonprofit organization by the IRS in 04/1987.  For the tax year of 2006, they held $778,642 in assets and had an income of $1,134,922.  Organizations performing similar types of work, on average, held only $311,304 in assets and had incomes of $610,576.  According to this site, there are only 42 other 509(a)(2) organizations performing similar activities in the country.  Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) is one, and is ranked as having the highest income for this tax period, at a whopping $41,775,641.  Amethyst Foundation, Inc., is ranked as the fifth at $1,134,922.

Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s income for the fiscal year 2010 was $1,134,922, as indicated by their IRS Form 900.  On this form, the organization's stated mission was: 

"To disseminate information concerning the effects on human beings of ingesting ethyl alcohol and other drugs; to assist individuals in assessing their own personal relationships with alcohol; to identify those individuals with drinking problems and involve them in a[n] alcohol awareness school--the organization operates a court and state mandated school for driving while under the influence of alcohol."

A search of the public records indicates that the state of New Hampshire contracts with Amethyst Foundation, Inc., for significant amounts of money.  For the period from July 1, 2010 to June 30, 2011, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., along with two other 509(a)(2) organizations, Serenity Place and Tri-County Community Action Program, shared $751,400 in tax payer money in the form of sole source contracts (one contract for $455,000 and one for $296,400).  Amethyst Foundation, Inc., has a registered lobbyist with the New Hampshire Legislature, Edward DuPont.  He's doing a very good job.  For one year, Amethyst Foundation, Inc., shared nearly one million dollars in sole source contract money--money provided by New Hampshire residents.

And because of Amethyst Foundation, Inc.'s IRS 509(a)(2) status, all of this income is tax free!  

I thought my IDIP program was expensive until I saw the prices for others offered by Amethyst Foundation:

Phase II (for 2nd Offenders), a seven day residential program......$1,550.00 
.....of which Amethyst keeps $1,300.00.

WIDIP ("Weekend Intoxicated Driver Intervention Program").........$585.00 
.....of which Amethyst keeps $485.00.

MOP ("Multiple Offender Program")...........................................$1,550.00
.....of which Amethyst keeps $1,300.00.

Of the $460 fee for the IDIP class, Amethyst keeps $410.

The state of New Hampshire gets the crumbs as administrative fees.

Amethyst Foundation does a big business, as I was later to find out.  The classes filled up quickly.  A lot of the "customers" were from out of state.  In fact, a LADC told me many are celebrities.  I was told Amethyst Foundation was the only residential facility in New England.

So, we have a nice, very profitable, "non profit" corporation that pays no taxes and receives a huge amount of taxpayer funds.  How much they charge is determined, not by the market, but by the New Hampshire legislature.  They do a huge business and, with ever stricter DUI laws, will never lack for customers.  What a sweet deal.